SmallBizGenius Analysis
Nine West, now primarily an online retailer, faces significant criticism regarding its customer service and product quality, with many customers reporting issues with returns, refunds, and the durability of their shoes and accessories. While some long-time customers appreciate the brand's enduring styles and occasional positive customer service experiences, the overwhelming sentiment leans negative.
Category Breakdown
Scores based on analysis of 96 recent reviews
Customer Service Issues
2.0/10Numerous reviewers express frustration with Nine West's customer service, citing long response times, unhelpful representatives, and difficulty resolving issues. Many report problems with obtaining refunds or exchanges, and some claim their inquiries are ignored entirely, exemplified by comments like "Non-existent Customer Service: Customer service does not respond."
45 reviews mention thisProduct Quality Decline
3.0/10Many customers feel the quality of Nine West products has declined significantly since the brand shifted to primarily online sales. Reviewers report shoes and accessories falling apart after minimal use, with complaints about cheap materials and poor construction, such as "Inferior quality, bad customer service" and "Disintegrating Ninewest Shoes."
38 reviews mention thisReturns and Refunds Problems
2.5/10A significant number of reviewers report difficulties with Nine West's return and refund process. Common issues include being charged for returns, not receiving full refunds, and encountering confusing or restrictive return policies, with some reviewers stating "Terrible return policy" and "Terrible customer service. Not refunding my money despite me returning the shoes."
32 reviews mention thisShipping and Delivery Issues
3.5/10Several customers report problems with shipping and delivery, including delayed orders, receiving the wrong items, and packages being lost or stolen. Some reviewers also mention issues with international orders and unexpected customs charges, as seen in comments like "Ordered boots on 11/25/23" detailing month-long delays and "Nine West South Africa site is a scam".
15 reviews mention thisSizing and Fit Inconsistencies
4.0/10A number of reviewers have experienced issues with inconsistent sizing and fit across different Nine West shoe styles. This makes online ordering difficult, as customers are unsure what size to purchase, leading to returns and frustration, with one reviewer noting "lnconsistent quality...one fits and others don’t."
8 reviews mention thisPros & Cons
What Customers Love
"The experience was hugely redeemed by a customer service agent who was prompt in emailing me back and providing a solution. I really appreciated her help."
"I gave it two stars because the design is elegant"
"Good customer service! They gave me a true assistance with my order!"
Common Complaints
"Customer service does not respond. I’ve been waiting weeks and every 48 hours I follow-up, still no reply."
"I was an avid buyer if Nine West shoes for work...after 2 months of wearing them maybe 2-3 times per week with minimal mileage the cheap plastic heal has come off."
"Terrible customer service, charge you to return shoes. I’ll never return to the company to purchase shoes again. Looks like all their customers feel this way. Worst return policy ever."
"I am so bummed that Nine West went down hill.I have ordered 5 pairs of shoes in the last month.I tried in the same shoe in the same show name/style, just in different colors and one fits and others don’t.It just doesn’t make sense so it’s a quality issue. Very inconsistent."
"Ordered boots on 11/25/23, I have had an issue with 1 pair of boots since I received them on 12/2/23...its been over 1 month since this started."
Common Questions About Nine West
Answers derived from customer review patterns
Is Nine West legit and trustworthy?
Based on 96 reviews, Nine West's legitimacy is questionable due to numerous reports of scams, undelivered items, and unauthorized charges. Many customers have reported receiving the wrong items, damaged goods, or nothing at all, leading them to believe the website is a scam. The lack of adequate customer service and difficulty in obtaining refunds further erode trust in the brand. While Nine West is a recognized brand, the online experience appears unreliable, and customers should exercise caution when making purchases.
Based on 15 reviewsDoes Nine West have good customer service?
Nine West's customer service receives overwhelmingly negative feedback. Customers frequently complain about long response times, unhelpful representatives, and difficulty resolving issues. Many reviewers report that their emails and calls go unanswered, and they struggle to get assistance with returns, refunds, or order problems. The consensus is that Nine West's customer service is severely lacking and contributes to a frustrating shopping experience.
Based on 45 reviewsIs Nine West worth it for small business?
For small businesses, Nine West is not a recommended vendor due to the high risk of inconsistent product quality and poor customer service. The numerous complaints about damaged goods, shipping errors, and difficulties with returns make it an unreliable source for business needs. Small businesses require dependable suppliers, and Nine West's current reputation suggests it cannot consistently meet those demands. The potential for negative customer experiences outweighs any perceived cost savings.
Based on 5 reviewsWhat is Nine West's return policy like?
Nine West's return policy is a frequent source of frustration for customers. Many reviewers report that they were charged for return shipping, even when the item was damaged or the wrong item was sent. Others complain about not receiving full refunds or being offered store credit instead of their original payment method. The lack of in-store returns for online purchases and confusing return procedures further complicate the process, making it difficult for customers to return unwanted or defective items.
Based on 32 reviewsWhy did Nine West close their stores?
Several reviewers mention that Nine West closed its physical storefronts in 2018, transitioning to a primarily online business model. While the reviews do not provide an official reason, speculation suggests it was due to financial difficulties and a shift in consumer shopping habits. This transition appears to have coincided with a decline in product quality and customer service, as many reviewers contrast their positive experiences with the brand's former brick-and-mortar presence with their current online shopping experience.
Based on 5 reviewsLooking for Something Different?
Compare Nine West against 522 similar lifestyle & perks options.
View Alternatives